You should find advantages and disadvantages for each.
Which one is better Microsoft Tag or QR Codes
You decide.
This TAG directs the reader to www.lunadevelopment.com our company website. Even this small your reader should have no difficulty in reading it.
We tested 12 different devices and all successfully read the code above. If somehow your device cannot read it, here is one just a little bigger.
- URL for a website
- Phone Call
- vCard (Contact)
- Text
While there are fewer TAG functions initially, remember that TAG is still in beta and the feature set is not yet finalized.
TAG requires an internet connection to function but. In many cases TAG information is returned from the internet by the time you are able to focus and capture a QR Code and even when both readers are using active mode. (Active-mode readers use a camera's video stream and test each frame as opposed to passive-mode, where you must take a picture first and then pass it to the reader.)
The TAG reader is exceptionally fast but since all TAGs are the same size relative to one another they are easier to capture and decrypt, resulting in blazingly fast performance. In many cases, you have to spend a lot of time focusing in on QR Codes to get the readers to work. Functionality is the biggest contributor to user experience and here TAG the clear advantage.
Don't take my word for it. Test it yourself but instead of holding your phone still, move it back and forth across the screen. And try it with our smallest TAG - the one shown above. Don not stop and do not try to focus, just keep moving closer and closer until it reads the TAG.
Even better, increase your screen size by about 500% making the TAG much larger. Then start from several feet away and as you move your phone closer to the screen, twist or rotate the phone back and forth. The test here is to see how fast you have to twist and turn, in order not to read the TAG. Be careful, if you slow down too much it will be too easy.
The size of TAG above on the actual business card is 3/4" x 3/4". And if you were to scan it you would find just what you'd expect - contact information but no rule says that's what the TAG needs to point to.
Over 30 years ago, George Cohan, the CEO of McDonald's Canada gave out business cards that were redeemable for a Big Mac. So who's to say what your code does. It all depends on what you want people to do with it. In fact, business cards are such a convenient size they could have any purpose.
It certainly isn't all about aesthetics but it is immediately clear that custom TAGs will be a big part of the market and they look good too. Although you can still tell it's a TAG, in some circumstances you should be able to blend such TAGs right into your document.
And here is a TAG that is almost completely void of clues that is a TAG.
Not to take anything away from the effort that companies like 3G Vision and NTT DoCoMo have put into making 2D barcodes a mainstream technology BUT they've been at it for 7 years. In all that time, they have yet to move away from the "click a code - go to a web page" mentality. And yet there is so much more.
If Microsoft has learned anything in three decades, it is developers, developers, developers. TAG is starting life with developers in mind right out of the box. Why? Because the demand for TAG solutions will outpace everything a single company can provide and because the breadth of applications demands effort across multiple disciplines.
There are an estimated 4 million developers programming on one windows platform or another. Given that the current development tools make the transition to mobile painless, means that, there can be 4 million TAG developers available inside a year.
With Windows Mobile and Windows Phone there will always be a transitional platform for windows developers. No matter what it's called the combination of mobile operating system, embedded database and other subsystems have and will be available to meet the demand we anticipate the TAG will generate.
That may seem like a motherhood statement but the simple fact is there is going to be a lot of demand and no other pool of developers exist that can scale along with the demands of TAG.
In addition, no other mobile operating system has comes even close in ability to connect like applications like SQL databases, or the Dynamics line like GP and CRM as well as a host of other backend systems.
This TAG actually returns a single character, lowercase "a". By itself that's not really much use unless it formed some part of a word game or puzzle or perhaps a contest but it's mainly shown to make a comparison with the TAG below.
Now this TAG will return 990 characters, about the biggest we could create with our tools right now. It doesn't look that much different from the single character TAG above. They are the same size and a TAG that returned a million characters would not be any bigger. You may never have a reason to do this but applications that want to use this functionality in TAG certainly do.
To highlight the point, open the 1000 character QR Code to the right. It has 1000 "a's" but you will have to take our word for it since none of the phone readers can read it.
Each of these codes point to the same URL. However, not all phones can read the smaller codes. The reason is in part due to the different cameras used, the differences in the software Reader companies use and probably a combination of both.
If you have any difficulty reading the codes, you can try magnifying the screen or printing the page. On some monitors lighting can have a negative effect but the real purpose is to use printed codes so testing on the screen is less critical.
Notice also that the code itself looks different from the ones above. They all point to the same place. It's just that different code generators produce different results. You can create your own to test using our QRender, you'll find it elsewhere on this site or try other ones on the web.
- URL for a website
- Bookmark (Favorite)
- Phone Call
- SMS message
- Email message
- vCard (Contact)
- Text
- Encryption
- Geographical Coordinates
- Jigsaw
TAG requires an internet connection to function but in many cases information is returning from the internet, by the time you are able to focus and capture a QR Code. This is the same even when both readers are using active mode. (Active-mode readers use a camera's video stream and test each frame as opposed to passive-mode, where you must take a picture must and then pass it to the reader.)
The TAG reader is exceptionally fast but since all TAGs are the same size relative to one another, they are easier to capture and decrypt resulting in consistently fast performance over all TAGs. Extremely small or large QR Codes can be difficult if not impossible for many readers.
There is far too much disinformation floating around for us to quote statistic; however, 3gVision have indicated they have over 80 million users in Japan and that their installed based is 120 million. So if the figure of 75% utilization in Japan is true, then that's at least 60 million regular users and that is a market to take notice of.
Over the years, we have seen a number of custom QR Codes. Since most of those we have seen are designed for the Japanese market it is more it is difficult to gain an appreciation. However, it is clear from the code at the right that the character and symbols are intentional and that the code can accommodate error correctionpleasing.
Perhaps there is a cultural difference at work here but it is clear that codes can be integrated with varying styles and patterns.
Once again, we have an example of a QR Code that is pleasing and tastefully designed. Remember, QR Codes have been used on mobile devices in Japan since 2003 and with that amount of lead-time we should consider that a mature market.